Language Disclaimer
The original language of this website is English. Translations are automatically generated for user convenience. We do not guarantee the accuracy or completeness of translated content, especially for medical or technical terms.
In case of discrepancies, the English version prevails, particularly for product details, regulatory content, and safety information. This aligns with our obligations under the MDR (EU) 2017/745 and our commitment to clear, accurate communication.
Medical and Regulatory Disclaimer
This website is intended exclusively for healthcare professionals and provides general, non-promotional information regarding MTS Medical’s technologies and manufacturing capabilities. Its content is not a subsitute for medical advice offer, diagnosis or treatment. Patients should always consult a qualified healthcare professional for medical guidance.
MTS Medical’s products are medical devices subject to the regulatory framework of their respective markets. Please be aware that product availability, regulatory clearances, and certifications may vary by country.
The information presented does not constitute a guarantee of market authorization in any specific territory. For country-specific regulatory status, availability, and approved indications for use, please contact your authorized local distributor or sales partner.
Privacy Policy
Last updated: 19.08.2026
Controller
The controller responsible for data processing on this website is:
MTS Medical AG
Robert-Bosch-Str. 18
78467 Konstanz, Germany
Phone: +49 (0)7531 36185-0
Email: info@mts-medical.com
The controller decides, either alone or jointly with others, on the purposes and means of processing personal data (e.g. names, contact details or similar information).
Data Protection Officer
You can contact our Data Protection Officer by email at datenschutz@mts-medical.com or by post at the address above with the addition "For the attention of the Data Protection Officer".
Withdrawal of your consent to data processing
Some data processing operations are only possible with your express consent. You may withdraw consent already given at any time. An informal notification by email is sufficient for this purpose. The lawfulness of data processing carried out before the withdrawal remains unaffected by the withdrawal.
Right to lodge a complaint with the competent supervisory authority
As a data subject, you have the right to lodge a complaint with a supervisory authority in the event of a data protection violation. The supervisory authority responsible for us is the State Commissioner for Data Protection and Freedom of Information Baden-Württemberg (LfDI Baden-Württemberg), Lautenschlagerstraße 20, 70173 Stuttgart, Germany.
Right to data portability
You have the right to receive data that we process automatically on the basis of your consent or in performance of a contract, either yourself or through a third party. The data will be provided in a machine-readable format. If you request the direct transfer of the data to another controller, this will only be carried out where technically feasible.
Right of access, rectification, restriction of processing and erasure
Within the scope of the applicable statutory provisions, you have the right at any time to obtain free information about your stored personal data, the origin of the data, its recipients and the purpose of the data processing and, where applicable, a right to rectification, restriction of processing or erasure of this data. For this purpose, and for any other questions relating to personal data, you may contact us at any time using the contact details above.
Information on the online services offered on this website Server log files
Our hosting provider automatically collects and stores information in server log files that your browser automatically transmits to us. This includes:
-
Page visited on our domain
-
Date and time of the server request
-
Browser type and browser version
-
Operating system used
-
Referrer URL
-
Host name of the accessing computer
-
IP address
This data is not merged with other data sources. Server log data is processed on the basis of Art. 6(1)(f) GDPR. Our legitimate interest lies in the secure, stable and technically error-free provision of our website and in preventing and investigating misuse and security incidents. The log data is deleted as soon as it is no longer required for these purposes.
Cookies
Our website uses cookies. These are small text files that your web browser stores on your device. Cookies help us make our services more user-friendly, effective and secure.
Some cookies are "session cookies". These cookies are automatically deleted at the end of your browser session. Other cookies remain on your device until you delete them yourself. Such cookies help us recognise you when you return to our website.
Modern web browsers allow you to monitor, restrict or prevent the setting of cookies. Many web browsers can be configured to delete cookies automatically when the program is closed. Disabling cookies may restrict the functionality of our website.
Technically necessary cookies and comparable storage or access operations that are strictly necessary to provide a digital service expressly requested by you are used on the basis of Section 25(2) TDDDG. Where personal data is processed in this context, the processing is based on Art. 6(1)(f) GDPR; our legitimate interest lies in the technically secure and functional provision of our website.
For all cookies and comparable technologies that are not technically necessary, we obtain your consent before they are used. In these cases, the storage of information on your device or access to information already stored on your device is based on Section 25(1) TDDDG; the subsequent processing of personal data is based on Art. 6(1)(a) GDPR. You may withdraw or change your consent at any time with effect for the future via the cookie settings.
Usercentrics (Cookie Consent Management)
We use the Usercentrics consent management platform (CMP) on our website to obtain, manage and verifiably document our users' consent to cookies and other tracking technologies. The provider is Usercentrics GmbH, Sendlinger Straße 7, 80331 Munich, Germany.
When you access our website, the following data is processed: date and time of access, browser and device information, IP address, your cookie preferences and the URL of the page visited. The processing is carried out to fulfil our legal obligation to provide evidence under Art. 7(1) GDPR, for which Art. 6(1)(c) GDPR provides the legal basis; without this processing, the functionality of our cookie banner cannot be ensured.
Usercentrics processes personal data as our processor in accordance with Art. 28 GDPR. Under the Data Processing Agreement concluded with Usercentrics, processing generally takes place within the EU/EEA. Where subprocessors or processing activities in third countries are used in individual cases, this takes place only in compliance with the requirements of Art. 44 et seq. GDPR, in particular on the basis of an adequacy decision or appropriate safeguards such as the Standard Contractual Clauses of the European Commission. You may change or withdraw your cookie preferences at any time via the cookie settings icon on our website. Further information can be found in the Usercentrics privacy policy: https://usercentrics.com/de/datenschutzerklaerung/.
Hosting and email delivery
The hosting services we use serve to provide the following services: infrastructure and platform services, computing capacity, storage space and database services, email delivery, security services and technical maintenance services used by us to operate this online offering.
In this context, we or our hosting provider process master data, contact data, content data, contract data, usage data, metadata and communication data of customers, interested parties and visitors to this online offering on the basis of our legitimate interests in the efficient and secure provision of this online offering pursuant to Art. 6(1)(f) GDPR in conjunction with Art. 28 GDPR (conclusion of a data processing agreement).
Wix
Our website is created and operated using the Wix website builder provided by Wix.com Ltd., 40 Namal Tel Aviv St., Tel Aviv, Israel. When you use our website, Wix may process, in particular, IP addresses as well as technical usage and communication data. We have entered into a data processing agreement with Wix in accordance with Art. 28 GDPR.
The processing is based on our legitimate interest in the technically secure, stable and appealing provision of our online offering pursuant to Art. 6(1)(f) GDPR. Data transfers to Wix.com Ltd. in Israel are covered by an adequacy decision of the European Commission pursuant to Art. 45 GDPR. Where data is transferred to Wix.com Inc. in the USA, the transfer is based on the EU-US Data Privacy Framework to the extent covered by the certification; in addition, the group-internal protection mechanisms and appropriate safeguards implemented by Wix apply. Further information: https://www.wix.com/about/privacy.
Wix Analytics
With your consent, we use Wix Analytics, a statistics function provided by Wix.com Ltd. (see "Wix" above), to understand how visitors use our website. Wix Analytics processes information such as device type and operating system, browser type and version, pages visited and time spent on them, traffic sources and approximate geographic location based on a shortened IP address. We use this information to improve the performance, content and usability of our website.
Wix Analytics is activated only after you have given your consent via our consent management platform. The legal basis for accessing information on your device is Section 25(1) TDDDG; the subsequent processing of personal data is based on Art. 6(1)(a) GDPR. You may withdraw your consent at any time with effect for the future via the cookie settings. Information on data transfers to Wix can be found in the "Wix" section above.
Contact form
Data submitted via the contact form, including your contact details, is stored so that we can process your enquiry or be available for follow-up questions. This data will not be disclosed without your consent.
The processing of data submitted via the contact form depends on the content of your enquiry. If your enquiry relates to the initiation or performance of a contract, Art. 6(1)(b) GDPR is the legal basis. For other enquiries, processing is based on Art. 6(1)(f) GDPR; our legitimate interest lies in properly processing and responding to your enquiry. Where we expressly obtain consent for individual processing activities, Art. 6(1)(a) GDPR is the legal basis; consent granted may be withdrawn at any time with effect for the future.
Data submitted via the contact form will remain with us until you request erasure, withdraw your consent to storage or the purpose for storing the data no longer applies. Mandatory statutory provisions – in particular retention periods – remain unaffected.
HubSpot forms
We use forms from the provider HubSpot on our website. The provider is HubSpot, Inc., 25 First Street, Cambridge, MA 02141, USA; HubSpot Ireland Limited, 1 Sir John Rogerson's Quay, Dublin 2, Ireland, also operates in Europe. The data you enter into forms, in particular your name, email address and other voluntary information, is processed for handling contact and prospective-customer enquiries.
Depending on the content of the enquiry, processing is based on Art. 6(1)(b) GDPR or, where consent is obtained, on Art. 6(1)(a) GDPR. We have entered into a data processing agreement with HubSpot in accordance with Art. 28 GDPR.
HubSpot, Inc. is certified under the EU-US Data Privacy Framework. To the extent a transfer to HubSpot, Inc. is covered by this certification, it is carried out on the basis of the European Commission's adequacy decision pursuant to Art. 45 GDPR. In addition, the HubSpot Data Processing Agreement provides for appropriate safeguards. Further information is available at https://legal.hubspot.com/privacy-policy.
Integration and use of third-party services and content
General information on the integration of third-party services and content
Within our online offering, we use content or service offerings from third-party providers in order to integrate their content and services, such as videos or maps (collectively referred to below as "content"). Where the integration requires access to your device or is not technically necessary, we only load the content after you have given your consent via our consent management platform; the specific legal bases are stated in the sections below.
Integrating such content always requires the third-party providers to receive the users' IP address, as they would otherwise be unable to send the content to the users' browsers. The IP address is therefore required to display this content. We endeavour to use only content whose respective providers use the IP address solely for delivering the content. Third-party providers may also use pixel tags (invisible graphics, also known as "web beacons") for statistical or marketing purposes. Pixel tags can be used to evaluate information such as visitor traffic on the pages of this website. Pseudonymous information may also be stored in cookies on users' devices and may include technical information about the browser and operating system, referring websites, visit times and other information on the use of our online offering, and may also be linked to such information from other sources.
YouTube
Videos from the YouTube service are embedded on our website. The provider is Google Ireland Limited, Gordon House, Barrow Street, Dublin 4, Ireland; the parent company is Google LLC, 1600 Amphitheatre Parkway, Mountain View, CA 94043, USA.
Embedded YouTube content is activated only after you have given your consent via our consent management platform. Upon activation, your IP address, device and usage information in particular may be transmitted to Google, and cookies or comparable technologies may be used. The legal basis for accessing information on your device is Section 25(1) TDDDG; the subsequent processing of personal data is based on Art. 6(1)(a) GDPR. You may withdraw your consent at any time with effect for the future via the cookie settings.
Data transfers to certified US recipients of Google may take place on the basis of the European Commission's adequacy decision for the EU-US Data Privacy Framework; in addition, appropriate safeguards, in particular Standard Contractual Clauses, may be used. Further information is available at https://policies.google.com/privacy.
Google Maps
We integrate maps from the Google Maps service. The provider is Google Ireland Limited, Gordon House, Barrow Street, Dublin 4, Ireland; the parent company is Google LLC, 1600 Amphitheatre Parkway, Mountain View, CA 94043, USA.
Google Maps is activated only after you have given your consent via our consent management platform. Upon activation, your IP address and, if you allow this in your device settings, your location data may be transmitted to Google, and cookies or comparable technologies may be used. The legal basis for accessing information on your device is Section 25(1) TDDDG; the subsequent processing of personal data is based on Art. 6(1)(a) GDPR. You may withdraw your consent at any time with effect for the future via the cookie settings.
Data transfers to certified US recipients of Google may take place on the basis of the European Commission's adequacy decision for the EU-US Data Privacy Framework; in addition, appropriate safeguards, in particular Standard Contractual Clauses, may be used. Privacy policy: https://policies.google.com/privacy; opt-out: https://adssettings.google.com/authenticated.
Links to social networks
Our website contains only external links to our profiles on social networks and platforms, namely LinkedIn, Facebook, Instagram and YouTube. We do not use social media plugins, Like buttons or comparable embedded functions from these providers on our website.
Accordingly, merely visiting our website does not result in personal data being transferred to the respective social networks as a result of these links. Only when you click such a link do you leave our website, and the privacy provisions of the respective platform provider then apply.
Google Ads and Google conversion tracking
Our website uses Google Ads, an online advertising service. The provider is Google Ireland Limited, Gordon House, Barrow Street, Dublin 4, Ireland; the parent company is Google LLC, 1600 Amphitheatre Parkway, Mountain View, CA 94043, USA.
How Google Ads and conversion tracking work: After you click an advertisement placed by Google, a cookie is set for conversion tracking. These conversion cookies expire after 30 days and are not used to personally identify users. Google and we can use the cookie to determine that you clicked on an advertisement and were redirected to our website. Each Google Ads customer receives its own cookie; these cookies cannot be tracked across the websites of other Google Ads customers. As an Ads customer, we learn how many users clicked on our advertisement and were redirected to a page with a conversion tracking tag. However, we do not receive any information that enables us to personally identify users.
Legal basis and consent: Google Ads conversion tracking is activated only after you have given your consent via our consent management platform. The legal basis for accessing information on your device is Section 25(1) TDDDG; the subsequent processing of personal data is based on Art. 6(1)(a) GDPR. You may withdraw your consent at any time with effect for the future via the cookie settings.
Automated decisions: The use of Google Ads may involve automated decisions, for example the delivery of targeted advertisements based on collected data. You have the right not to be subject to a decision based solely on automated processing where that decision produces legal effects concerning you or similarly significantly affects you.
Data transfer to the USA: In connection with the use of Google Ads and conversion tracking, personal data may be transferred to and stored on Google servers in the USA. Google LLC is certified under the EU-US Data Privacy Framework; transfers are based on the European Commission's corresponding adequacy decision. Further information: https://www.dataprivacyframework.gov/. Up-to-date information on data processing by Google can be found at https://policies.google.com/privacy.
Google Tag Manager
Google Tag Manager is a solution that enables us to manage website tags through an interface and integrate other services into our online offering. The provider is Google Ireland Limited, Gordon House, Barrow Street, Dublin 4, Ireland. When Tag Manager is used, technical information, in particular IP address and device information, may be processed and transmitted to Google. Any additional data processed depends on the services integrated via Tag Manager; the relevant sections of this privacy policy apply.
Cookies and data processing: Where Google Tag Manager is used to integrate services, cookies or comparable technologies that are not technically necessary, these are activated only after you have given your consent. In these cases, the legal basis for accessing information on your device is Section 25(1) TDDDG and, for the subsequent processing of personal data, Art. 6(1)(a) GDPR. Technically necessary operations are used without consent only to the extent permitted by law.
Data transfer to the USA: Data collected by tags implemented through Google Tag Manager may be transmitted to Google servers in the USA. Google LLC is certified under the EU-US Data Privacy Framework; transfers are based on the European Commission's corresponding adequacy decision.
Opt-out options: You can change your consent at any time via the cookie settings. You can also configure your web browser to block cookies; disabling cookies may restrict the functionality of our website. Further details: Google Tag Manager use policy.
Web fonts
We use web fonts (including Google Fonts) to ensure consistent font display. The required font files are delivered from the servers of our website provider Wix and are not retrieved from Google servers when you visit our website. Therefore, the use of these fonts does not result in the transfer of your IP address or other personal data to Google, and no consent is required for them.
Newsletter
The following information explains the content of our newsletter, the registration and delivery process, statistical evaluation procedures and your rights to object. By subscribing to our newsletter, you agree to receive it and to the procedures described.
Newsletter content: We send newsletters, emails and other electronic notifications containing promotional information (hereinafter "newsletter") only with the recipients' consent or on the basis of a statutory permission. Where the content of the newsletter is specifically described during registration, that description is decisive for the user's consent. Our newsletters generally contain information about our products, services and our company.
Mailing service provider: We send our newsletter using HubSpot (see "HubSpot forms" above for provider details, data processing agreement and data transfers).
Double opt-in and logging: Registration for our newsletter uses the double opt-in procedure. This means that after registering, you receive an email asking you to confirm your registration. This confirmation is necessary to ensure that no one registers using another person's email address. Newsletter registrations are logged so that the registration process can be demonstrated in accordance with legal requirements. This includes storing the time of registration and confirmation as well as the IP address. Changes to your data stored with the mailing service provider are also logged.
Registration data: To subscribe to the newsletter, it is sufficient to provide your email address. In individual cases, we may also ask for your name so that we can address you personally in the newsletter.
Legal basis: The newsletter and the related performance measurement are sent on the basis of your consent pursuant to Art. 6(1)(a) GDPR and Art. 7 GDPR in conjunction with Section 7(2) No. 3 UWG or, where consent is not required, on the basis of our legitimate interests in direct marketing pursuant to Art. 6(1)(f) GDPR in conjunction with Section 7(3) UWG. Where personal data is transferred to countries outside the EEA in connection with newsletter delivery, this takes place only in accordance with the requirements of Art. 44 et seq. GDPR, in particular on the basis of an adequacy decision of the European Commission (e.g. for certified US recipients under the EU-US Data Privacy Framework) or on appropriate safeguards such as the European Commission's Standard Contractual Clauses.
Unsubscribing: You may unsubscribe from our newsletter at any time, i.e. withdraw your consent. An unsubscribe link is included at the end of every newsletter. After unsubscribing, we store your email address for up to three years on the basis of our legitimate interests in order to demonstrate that consent had previously been given. Processing of this data is restricted to the purpose of defending against potential claims. An individual request for erasure may be made at any time, provided that the previous existence of consent is confirmed at the same time.
Newsletter performance measurement
The newsletters contain a so-called "web beacon", i.e. a one-pixel file that is retrieved from our server or, where we use a mailing service provider, from that provider's server when the newsletter is opened. During this retrieval, technical information is initially collected, such as information about the browser and your system, as well as your IP address and the time of retrieval.
This information is used for the technical improvement of the services on the basis of technical data, or for analysing target groups and their reading behaviour based on their retrieval locations (which can be determined using the IP address) or access times. Statistical analyses also include determining whether newsletters are opened, when they are opened and which links are clicked. For technical reasons, this information can be associated with individual newsletter recipients. However, neither we nor, where applicable, the mailing service provider seek to monitor individual users. Rather, the analyses help us identify users' reading habits and adapt our content to them or send different content according to users' interests.
It is not possible to withdraw consent separately for performance measurement; in this case the entire newsletter subscription must be cancelled.
General Terms and Conditions
Privacy information for customers, suppliers and prospective customers
The following information provides you with an overview of how we process your personal data and of the rights available to you under the General Data Protection Regulation (EU GDPR) and the German Federal Data Protection Act (BDSG). The website-specific information above applies additionally to users of our website.
1. Who is responsible for data processing and whom can I contact?
The controller within the meaning of Art. 4 No. 7 GDPR is MTS Medical AG, Robert-Bosch-Str. 18, 78467 Konstanz, Germany, info@mts-medical.com. You can contact our Data Protection Officer at datenschutz@mts-medical.com or by post at the address above with the addition "For the attention of the Data Protection Officer".
2. Types of data and categories of data subjects
We process the following types of data: master data (e.g. names, addresses); contact data (e.g. email, telephone numbers); contract and order data (e.g. orders, billing address, delivery address and delivery history); payment data (e.g. bank details, payment history, payment methods, open-items list, reminders).
Data subjects are customers, suppliers, prospective customers and other relevant business partners. We process only data that is connected with entering into a contract or with pre-contractual measures. This may include general information about you or persons in your company (name, address, contact details), as well as any additional data you provide to us in connection with the initiation of a contract.
3. Purpose and legal basis of data processing
We process your personal data in accordance with the provisions of the EU GDPR and the BDSG. Where the provision of personal data is necessary for entering into, performing or fulfilling a contract or for carrying out pre-contractual measures, the processing is based on Art. 6(1)(b) GDPR.
If you give us consent to process personal data for specific purposes (e.g. disclosure to third parties, evaluation for marketing purposes or promotional contact), the lawfulness of this processing is based on your consent pursuant to Art. 6(1)(a) GDPR. Consent granted may be withdrawn at any time with effect for the future (see Section 7).
Where necessary and legally permissible, we process your data beyond the actual contractual purposes in order to comply with legal obligations pursuant to Art. 6(1)(c) GDPR. In addition, processing may take place to safeguard our legitimate interests or those of third parties pursuant to Art. 6(1)(f) GDPR. Where required by law, we will inform you of the relevant legitimate interest.
4. Recipients of the data
Within our company, we disclose your personal data only to those departments and persons that require the data in order to fulfil contractual and legal obligations or to safeguard our legitimate interests. We may transfer your personal data to affiliated companies to the extent permitted for the purposes and on the legal bases set out in Section 3.
Your personal data is processed on our behalf on the basis of data processing agreements pursuant to Art. 28 GDPR. In these cases, we ensure that personal data is processed in accordance with the GDPR. Categories of recipients in this context include providers of IT and ERP systems (Haufe Lexware, ACP-Solutions).
Otherwise, data is disclosed to recipients outside the company only where this is legally permitted or required, where the transfer is necessary for processing and thus performing the contract or, at your request, for carrying out pre-contractual measures, where we have your consent, or where we are entitled to provide information. Under these conditions, recipients of personal data may include, for example, public authorities and institutions (e.g. public prosecutor's offices, police, supervisory authorities, tax authorities) where there is a statutory or official obligation, and recipients to whom disclosure is directly necessary for entering into or performing a contract.
5. Transfer of data outside the EU
Personal data is transferred to countries outside the European Economic Area (EEA) or to international organisations only where this is necessary for the purposes stated in this privacy information and is permissible under data protection law. We comply with the requirements of Art. 44 et seq. GDPR. Transfers may be based in particular on an adequacy decision of the European Commission, on appropriate safeguards such as the European Commission's Standard Contractual Clauses or – in the exceptional cases provided for by law – on Art. 49 GDPR. Where required for the performance of a contract, recipients in third countries may include, for example, local business partners, service providers, agencies, airlines or hotels.
6. Duration of data storage
Where necessary, we process and store your personal data for the duration of our business relationship or for the fulfilment of contractual purposes. This includes, among other things, the initiation and performance of a contract.
In addition, we are subject to various retention and documentation obligations arising, among other things, from the German Commercial Code (Section 257 HGB) and the German Fiscal Code (AO). The retention or documentation periods prescribed there range from two to ten years. The retention period also depends on statutory limitation periods, which under Sections 195 et seq. of the German Civil Code (BGB) are generally three years and, in certain cases, may be up to thirty years.
7. Your rights
Every data subject has the right of access under Art. 15 GDPR, the right to rectification under Art. 16 GDPR, the right to erasure under Art. 17 GDPR, the right to restriction of processing under Art. 18 GDPR, the right to notification under Art. 19 GDPR and the right to data portability under Art. 20 GDPR.
In addition, you have the right to lodge a complaint with a data protection supervisory authority pursuant to Art. 77 GDPR if you believe that the processing of your personal data is unlawful. The right to lodge a complaint is without prejudice to any other administrative or judicial remedy.
Where processing is based on your consent, you have the right to withdraw your consent to the use of your personal data at any time pursuant to Art. 7 GDPR. Please note that withdrawal is effective only for the future. Processing carried out before the withdrawal is not affected. Please also note that, in certain circumstances, we may be required to retain certain data for a specified period in order to comply with legal requirements (see Section 6).
Right to object
Where your personal data is processed to safeguard legitimate interests pursuant to Art. 6(1)(f) GDPR, you have the right under Art. 21 GDPR to object at any time, on grounds relating to your particular situation, to the processing of this data. We will then no longer process this personal data unless we can demonstrate compelling legitimate grounds for the processing that override your interests, rights and freedoms, or the processing serves to establish, exercise or defend legal claims.
In individual cases, we process your personal data for direct marketing purposes. You have the right to object at any time to the processing of your data for such marketing. If you object to processing for direct marketing purposes, we will no longer process your personal data for these purposes. Please feel free to contact us to exercise your rights.
8. Requirement to provide personal data
The provision of personal data for the purpose of entering into, performing or fulfilling a contract or for carrying out pre-contractual measures is generally neither legally nor contractually required. You are therefore not obliged to provide personal data. Please note, however, that such data is generally necessary for deciding whether to enter into a contract, for performing a contract or for pre-contractual measures. If you do not provide us with personal data, we may not be able to make a decision or take action in connection with contractual measures. We recommend that you provide us only with personal data that is necessary for entering into a contract, fulfilling a contract or carrying out pre-contractual measures.
9. Automated decision-making
For the establishment, performance or conduct of the business relationship and for pre-contractual measures, we generally do not use fully automated decision-making pursuant to Art. 22 GDPR. Should we use such procedures in individual cases, we will inform you separately or obtain your consent where required by law.